Showing posts with label Priyanka Chakraborty. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Priyanka Chakraborty. Show all posts

Thursday, 30 August 2012

Accommodation Theory

Accommodation theory states that when people talk to each other, they adjust their behavior and manner of speech to take account of, "to accommodate", the topic, the circumstances, and the other people engaged with them in the conversation. For example: people talk more slowly to foreigners and use baby talk when interacting with infants. The way people communicate with each other is central to the kind of social interaction at issue.

Thus, friends and lovers, and especially people in the process of becoming friends and lovers, make every effort to converge in manner, accent, tone and topic. Someone wishing to keep his distance or disagree will always adopt a manner of speaking, expressing differently from that of the other party.

These ideas matter because it is clear that difficulties experienced by immigrants and foreigners everwhere arise in part from the difference of their speech mannerisms, and the limits tot their ability to 'converge' with native speakers when trying to communicate. As world globalizes further at an increasingly rapid pace, and as a major migrations of people especially from the southern to the northern hemisphere continue, so the problems and too often frictions increase: accommodation theory, for all its surface simplicity, gives insights into how miscommunication  and misinterpretation happen and how matters can be improved.

Accommodation theory was devised in the early 1970's by Howard Giles, whose first insights into communication came while working in a medical clinic in Wales. He wrote "the patients I took to the physicians just had to open their mouths and speak and I could predict the manner in which the physicians were going to deal with them." The ideas he developed have been applied by advertisers and party political researchers in thinking about the effective ways of getting the message across the target audience, and by business management training, advising clients on how to behave in foreign countries.

The limits of accommodation theory are illustrated by the latter. Studies found that efforts used by western businessmen who over accommodated in order to please or partners among Japanese businessmen were in fact counterproductive. The danger is that behaviour which appears to involve mimicry of others can look like mockery; in the Japanese case the businessmen from Japan preferred the foreigners to foreigners.

Accommodation theory is of particular value among other things, thinking about ways of integrating immigrant communities into host communities, where integration is a term between assimilation and multiculturalism, just means providing a way for immigrants who to get along with the host communities to succeed economically. With mass immigration has come the realization that it is ineffective to expect immigrants to do all accommodation, and that has resulted in host community adjustments to take account of linguistic and cultural factors.

Wednesday, 29 August 2012

ALTRUISM

In primary sense, putting interest of others before one's own is known as altruism. The term 'altruism' was coined by Auguste Comte in 1851 from the Italian word 'altrui' which means 'others'. It literally means 'otherism'. The concept of altruism appears in most moral systems. The key aspect to altruism lies in "thinking about the good and nature of relationships and states that the question of what is owed to others, both in connection with particular obligations and generally, should occupy a central place."

A true altruist is a one who believes in selflessness and carries out his obligations to others without any consideration of his own self-interest. for example, when we cross a busy road and help someone cross along with us, that is not altruism. But when we help someone cross the road without considering whether we need to or not, that is altruism.

The founder of the concept of altruism believed that "individuals had a moral obligation to renounce self-interest and live for others." Comte says in his Catechisme Positiviste that, "social points of view cannot tolerate the notion of rights, for such notion rests on individualism. We are born under a load of obligation of every kind, to our predecessors, to our successors, to our contemporaries. After our birth these obligations increase or accumulate, for it is sometimes before we can return this service...This ['to live for others'], the definitive formula of human morality, gives us a direct sanction exclusively to our instincts of benevolence, the common source of happiness and duty. [Man must serve] Humanity whose we are entirely."

Altruism is an extreme concept.There is nothing called "true altruism" in practice. But whenever the term altruism is said, the name that comes immediately to my mind is Mother Teresa. She was as altruist as any individual could be. She gave up her life for the needy and poor. She says that, "By blood I am an Albanian. By citizenship an Indian. By faith I am a catholic. As to my calling, I belong to the world. As to my heart, I belong entirely to the heart of Jesus."

Mother Teresa is one in a million, and in reality, every deed which is enacted by an individual has a motive. The motive may not be money or power but it will then be pleasure or satisfaction. The practical aspect of altruism has often been criticized and, "critics have been quick to say that neither kin selection or reciprocal selection is 'true altruism' because of course  there is an advantage to the actors themselves in both kinds of case...Among conscious and and reflective human beings it might be expected that principles, beliefs, affections and interests and a sense of greater good might trump self-interests and even self-preservation at times-and that they often do." Hence, altruism may exist literally but it cannot exist in reality.

Monday, 2 July 2012

Chaucer's Wife of Bath's "foot-mantle" and "hipes large"

This is a report written by Priyanka Chakraborty on an article by Peter G. Beidler of Lehigh University, published by State Penn University in the year 2000.

     The Wife of Bath known for her gap teeth, her wimple, her hat, her five husbands, her deafness, her over-riding skirt, and her large hips. Alisoun's "hipes large" has piqued Chaucerian readers and scholars. The "hipes large" seem to indicate an imposing and commanding lady both in size and presence to not only browbeat her older husbands but also hold out marital battles with the younger ones.
     Peter.G.Beidler challenges that "foot-mantle" is not a skirt or a protective outer skirt. He also challenges that Alisoun did not have large hips. He goes on to say that old English translators and  editors generally translate "foot-mantle" as an "outer protective skirt", "apron like over-skirt", 'an outer skirt to protect the gown as she rode along" or simply an "apron".
     Modern English translators and editors have glossed "foot-mantle" as a "saddle-blanket", "rug", "protective skirt", or  "plain skirt". Some translators have kept the word "mantle" assuming the modern readers will know what it is. If a modern reader looks up the word "mantle' in a dictionary, they maybe lured into thinking that it is some sort of cape or a cloak. In most of the cases, translators translate the word "mantle" and silently delete the prefix "foot" which is suggestive of the modern world's failure to understand what a "foot-mantle" is.
     Due to such translations, which is considered faulty and ambiguous by Peter.G.Beidler, the rarity of the term is hampered. The first and last recorded use of the word was done by Chaucer and the word was not in use for the next hundred years. He suggests that "foot-mantle" is what the words suggests it is. It is probably an one piece garment like a loose pair of leggings, worn to provide warmth to the lower extremities, protection for shoes from dirt and horse excreta, a regular part of horseback travel on the unpaved roads of Medieval
era. The prefix "foot" suggests that the garment is pulled over feet and legs rather than pulled down over. The "foot-mantle" must have been held by a belt or a suspender of some sort.
     Such a "foot-mantle" would have been necessary even for a woman of minimal modesty such as the Wife of Bath, wearing skirts while riding astride. The description of Alisoun in the General Prologue tells us that she was dressed elegantly for her pilgrimage. She must have wanted to protect her clothes especially her "hosen...of fyn scarlet reed" and her shoes "ful moyste and newe".
     There is a portrait known as the Ellesmere portrait, which was composed within ten years of Chaucer's death and it says with rare precision what a "foot-mantle" is. It is shown as a blue garment pulled over Alisoun's feet and were loosely around her hips with spurs either attached to it or to be fitted afterwards. The Ellesmere portrait cannot be considered as an accurate reflection the General Prologue but it can be considered as a pictorial gloss of the word "foot-mantle".
     Peter.G.Beidler says that there is such remarkable unanimity in the phrase "large hipes" that no editors have glossed it. In translations the word the word "large" has been translated as "ample'', "broad", "enormous". He says that instead of the adjective "large" it is the adverb "largely" or more accurately "loosely'. Going by that theory, the Wife of Bath does not wear a "foot-mantle" about her large hips but wears a "foot-mantle" pulled up loosely around her hips.
     Middle English adverbs could be formed by adding an "e" in which case the adjective and the adverb would be identical. Even though both the old and modern English translators have glossed "large" as an adjective but also shown clearly that it can be used as an adverb i.e. ''amply", "abundantly". Chaucer has used the word as an adjective in Diomede's "tonge large" and Urn's Preist "large breest". Chaucer undeniably does that  but he also uses "large" as an adverb.
                               
Everich a word, if it be in his charge
Al speke he never so rudeliche and large

     The word "large" has been used as an adverb modifying the word "speke" meaning freely or without restraint. The reason 'large" being an adverb has been ignored because in modern English  it is generally used as an adjective, so the fact that in middle English it can be a different part of speech, has been ignored.It may also be noted that Chaucer has been constrained to write in iambic couplets so the words which are implied has been left.


Upon an amblere esily she sat 
Ywympled wel, and on on head (she wore) an hat.
As brood as is a bokeler on a targe;   
(She wore) A foot-mantle about her hipes large,       
And on hir feet (she wore) a paire of spores sharpe.   


     It is only fair to imagine that a "foot-mantle" worn "largely" about her hips, her dress must have been pushed up around her hips inside the upper part of the "foot-mantle". So the largeness about her hips can be caused by bunched up dresses and not by the breadth themselves. Chaucer also knows hoe to tell his audience  of that a woman has large hips. Malyne of the Reeve's Tale has 'buttocks brode" and the White in Book of Duchess has hips of  "good brede".He hastens to say that such description by Chaucer are merely indicative of the lady's beauty and attractiveness. In neither of these cases does he describe the hips as "large" but as "brode".
     It must also be noted that Chaucer is only describing her clothing and not her body. He tells us about her wimple, hat, spur, but does not seem interested in her physical body and tells us only about her face because that is the only part the fellow traveller's can see. Her bold, fair, red face, gap teeth is all that is told about her body, so why out of blue would Chaucer talk about her hips when he could not even see them. It is also unusual that Chaucer would only describe her hips and no other part below her face. Reading "large'' as an adverb and describing her "foot-mantle" draped loosely around her hips would keep the focus on what Chaucer can see, her clothes.
     Certain medical research has been conducted on Alisoun's "obesity and her "massive girth" and some researchers like Catherine.S.Cox in 1993 said that Wife of  Bath is of male construct, eating and drinking too much and is quite fitting to describe as "hipes large" as having excessive flesh or girth and fails to describe any limit or boundary. The only evidence of her over-eating may or may not be "hipes large' but Chaucer does not give us those particular constructions.
     If so many interpretations arise from "large" being and adjective then maybe it should not be questioned any further. It is tempting to suggest that Chaucer has been deliberately ambiguous leaving it to the reader's imagination. But in his preference Peter.G.Beidler thinks that it is a pair of leggings pulled over "largely'' or "loosely" about her hips.
     If "large' is described as an adjective, then it indicates her physical stature.Generally imagined to be a big, strong woman capable of defending herself in the rough and tumble arenas of pilgrimage, business, marriage. Then the fact that she was subjected to domestic abuse by her former husband Jankyns cannot be ignored . She comments on her pain as "ribbes al by rewe" and "beten for a book". Perhaps she is not a weighty woman but someone who is small and vulnerable. We can also empathize with her for being the maiden of her own tale whose maidenhood was taken away by verray force by an impulsive knight.


     Here are the links to the Ellesmere portrait which shows with fair accuracy what a "foot-mantle" is and the JStor article mentioned above.